binkp.net and literal IPv6 addresses

Michiel van der Vlist написал(а) к binkp.net team в Feb 16 21:38:06 по местному времени:

Нello binkp.net team

There was something new in today's nodelist. For the first time there was a literal IPv6 address:

,303,lionsden.darktech.org,TrentonON,JoeDelahaye,1-613-392-8896,9600,
CM,XA,,V32b,V42b,VFC,
IBN:[2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef],IBN:lionsden.darktech.org

But there is no AAAA record for f303.n249.z1.binkp.net. only an A record.

Could you please upgrade the algorithm that generates the zone file for binkp.net to properly process literal IPv6 addresses in the nodelist?


Cheers, Michiel

--- GoldED+/W32-MINGW 1.1.5-b20110320

Alexey Vissarionov написал(а) к Michiel van der Vlist в Feb 16 13:39:00 по местному времени:

Доброго времени суток, Michiel!
05 Feb 2016 21:38:06, ты -> binkp.net team:

MvdV> There was something new in today's nodelist. For the first time
MvdV> there was a literal IPv6 address:
MvdV> ,303,lionsden.darktech.org,TrentonON,JoeDelahaye,1-613-392-8896,
MvdV> 9600,CM,XA,,V32b,V42b,VFC,IBN:[2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:
MvdV> c8ef],IBN:lionsden.darktech.org

Yes.

MvdV> But there is no AAAA record for f303.n249.z1.binkp.net. only an A
MvdV> record.

% host -t any f303.n249.z1.binkp.net.
f303.n249.z1.binkp.net is an alias for lionsden.darktech.org.

That's something we call "a CNAME record".

MvdV> Could you please upgrade the algorithm that generates the zone
MvdV> file for binkp.net to properly process literal IPv6 addresses
MvdV> in the nodelist?

Although the situation similar to this case of 1:249/303 was explicitly described in FTS-5004, the binkp.net doesn't conform to it, being just a proprietary DNS service, not a DDN.


--
Alexey V. Vissarionov aka Gremlin from Kremlin
gremlin ПРИ gremlin ТЧК ru; +vii-cmiii-ccxxix-lxxix-xlii

... Кто с чем к нам зачем - тот от того и того
--- /bin/vi

Pavel Gulchouck написал(а) к Michiel van der Vlist в Feb 16 17:39:14 по местному времени:

Нi Michiel!

05 Feb 16, Michiel van der Vlist ==> binkp.net team:

MvdV> There was something new in today's nodelist. For the first time there was a literal IPv6 address:

MvdV> ,303,lionsden.darktech.org,TrentonON,JoeDelahaye,1-613-392-8896,9600,
MvdV> CM,XA,,V32b,V42b,VFC,
MvdV> IBN:[2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef],IBN:lionsden.darktech.org

MvdV> But there is no AAAA record for f303.n249.z1.binkp.net. only an A record.

MvdV> Could you please upgrade the algorithm that generates the zone file for binkp.net to properly process literal IPv6
MvdV> addresses in the nodelist?

Fixed, thanks.

Lucky carrier,
Pavel
aka gul@gul.kiev.ua
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5

Pavel Gulchouck написал(а) к Alexey Vissarionov в Feb 16 17:40:02 по местному времени:

Нi Alexey!

06 Feb 16, Alexey Vissarionov ==> Michiel van der Vlist:

MvdV>> There was something new in today's nodelist. For the first time
MvdV>> there was a literal IPv6 address:
MvdV>> ,303,lionsden.darktech.org,TrentonON,JoeDelahaye,1-613-392-8896,
MvdV>> 9600,CM,XA,,V32b,V42b,VFC,IBN:[2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:
MvdV>> c8ef],IBN:lionsden.darktech.org

AV> Yes.

MvdV>> But there is no AAAA record for f303.n249.z1.binkp.net. only an A
MvdV>> record.

AV> % host -t any f303.n249.z1.binkp.net.
AV> f303.n249.z1.binkp.net is an alias for lionsden.darktech.org.

AV> That's something we call "a CNAME record".

MvdV>> Could you please upgrade the algorithm that generates the zone
MvdV>> file for binkp.net to properly process literal IPv6 addresses
MvdV>> in the nodelist?

AV> Although the situation similar to this case of 1:249/303 was explicitly described in FTS-5004, the binkp.net doesn't
AV> conform to it, being just a proprietary DNS service, not a DDN.

ddn.binkp.net is clear DDN service, and binkp.net contains all this data with some additional.
If it's not "conform to FTS-5004", then please tell me the domain that comforms it.

I look into your domain ddn.gremlin.ru, and there'is strange IPv6 for my (and it looks like for any other) node:

$ host -t any f68.n463.z2.ddn.gremlin.ru
f68.n463.z2.ddn.gremlin.ru has IPv6 address 2a01:4f8:131:32aa::1000
f68.n463.z2.ddn.gremlin.ru has address 46.4.14.152

Is it a bug?

Lucky carrier,
Pavel
aka gul@gul.kiev.ua
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5

Michiel van der Vlist написал(а) к Pavel Gulchouck в Feb 16 17:47:52 по местному времени:

Нello Pavel,

On Saturday February 06 2016 17:39, you wrote to me:

MvdV>> Could you please upgrade the algorithm that generates the zone
MvdV>> file for binkp.net to properly process literal IPv6 addresses
MvdV>> in the nodelist?

PG> Fixed, thanks.

Ping f303.n249.z1.binkp.net [2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef] mit 32 Bytes Daten:

Antwort von 2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef: Zeit=113ms
Antwort von 2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef: Zeit=119ms
Antwort von 2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef: Zeit=113ms
Antwort von 2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef: Zeit=109ms

Ping-Statistik fБr 2607:f2c0:f00e:4200:f9e0:b9ff:6166:c8ef:
Pakete: Gesendet = 4, Empfangen = 4, Verloren = 0 (0% Verlust),
Ca. Zeitangaben in Millisek.:
Minimum = 109ms, Maximum = 119ms, Mittelwert = 113ms

D:\FIDO>

Great! Thank you.


Cheers, Michiel

--- GoldED+/W32-MSVC 1.1.5-b20130111

Alexey Vissarionov написал(а) к Pavel Gulchouck в Feb 16 23:22:32 по местному времени:

Доброго времени суток, Pavel!
06 Feb 2016 17:40:02, ты -> мне:

PG> I look into your domain ddn.gremlin.ru, and there'is strange IPv6 for
PG> my (and it looks like for any other) node:
PG> $ host -t any f68.n463.z2.ddn.gremlin.ru
PG> f68.n463.z2.ddn.gremlin.ru has IPv6 address 2a01:4f8:131:32aa::1000
PG> f68.n463.z2.ddn.gremlin.ru has address 46.4.14.152

Next time try `head -c16 /dev/urandom | xxd -p`.gremlin.ru instead :-)

PG> Is it a bug?

No - that's just *.gremlin.ru at the "external" NS view.


--
Alexey V. Vissarionov aka Gremlin from Kremlin
gremlin ПРИ gremlin ТЧК ru; +vii-cmiii-ccxxix-lxxix-xlii

... Переливание из пустого в порожнее: cat /dev/zero > /dev/null
--- /bin/vi

Pavel Gulchouck написал(а) к Alexey Vissarionov в Feb 16 23:57:54 по местному времени:

Нi Alexey!

06 Feb 16, Pavel Gulchouck ==> Alexey Vissarionov:

[...]
AV>> % host -t any f303.n249.z1.binkp.net.
AV>> f303.n249.z1.binkp.net is an alias for lionsden.darktech.org.

AV>> That's something we call "a CNAME record".

AV>> Although the situation similar to this case of 1:249/303 was explicitly described in FTS-5004, the binkp.net doesn't
AV>> conform to it, being just a proprietary DNS service, not a DDN.

PG> ddn.binkp.net is clear DDN service, and binkp.net contains all this data with some additional.
PG> If it's not "conform to FTS-5004", then please tell me the domain that comforms it.

So, could you tell any FTS-5004 conforming DDN and not "just a proprietary DNS service"?

Lucky carrier,
Pavel
aka gul@gul.kiev.ua
--- GoldED+/LNX 1.1.5

Tommi Koivula написал(а) к Pavel Gulchouck в Feb 16 09:28:10 по местному времени:

* Originally in ru.binkd
* Crossposted in binkd

Нi Pavel.

06 Feb 16 17:39, you wrote to Michiel van der Vlist:

MvdV>> But there is no AAAA record for f303.n249.z1.binkp.net. only an
MvdV>> A record.

MvdV>> Could you please upgrade the algorithm that generates the zone
MvdV>> file for binkp.net to properly process literal IPv6 addresses
MvdV>> in the nodelist?

PG> Fixed, thanks.

Any chance of supporting ipv6 at dyn.binkp.net ? :)

'Tommi

---

Alexey Vissarionov написал(а) к Pavel Gulchouck в Feb 16 11:03:30 по местному времени:

Доброго времени суток, Pavel!
06 Feb 2016 23:57:54, ты -> мне:

PG> So, could you tell

Possibly, "name"?

PG> any FTS-5004 conforming

Possibly, "compliant"?

PG> DDN and not "just a proprietary DNS service"?

My own (grown from the PoC for former FSP-1035). Нowever, it's non-public pre-alpha, and, beyond that, I prefer to use explicit host names in ${echotag} configuration.


--
Alexey V. Vissarionov aka Gremlin from Kremlin
gremlin ПРИ gremlin ТЧК ru; +vii-cmiii-ccxxix-lxxix-xlii

... Хайло (сущ.): инструмент для руководства горными и земляными работами
--- /bin/vi